Phaedo: immortality of soul in the dialogue phaedo plato discusses the immortality of the soul he presents four different arguments to prove the fact that although the body of the human perishes after death the soul still exists and remains eternal. In his discussion of the immortality of the soul and resurrection of the body, with an eye toward countering the contemporary trend to view them as inherently incompatible doctrines. The soul, viz the resurrection of the body, is not an essential affirmation for the first christians but simply an accommodation to the mythological expressions of the thought of their time, and that the heart of the matter is the immortality of the soul. Resurrection is a christian, materialist view that the body rises after death in a physical form, with the main evidence of this being the resurrection of jesus christ resurrection is central to the christian faith as it marks the start of christianity from the jewish scriptures.
In conclusion, both the immortality of the soul and resurrection of the body are convincing positions, but to some extent, the immortality of the soul is more a convincing idea, this is because although resurrection does play a major role in the bible, plato, kant and descartes all give convincing arguments to dualism. 1 compare and contrast the immortality of the soul and the resurrection of the body the concept of the immortality of the soul is a dualist one, meaning that the body and soul are two separate entities. Resurrection is consistent with dualism if it is coupled with the notion of a soul which constitutes the personality and thus does not extinguish with the body at death but continues to exist and is later rejoined to a resurrected body (flew, god 108. If immortality of the soul is the case of the immortal soul freed from the body, we might have expected a more socratic jesus instead he is frightened, reduced to tears this is why the third day is such a shocking, shattering surprise.
Resurrection or a resurrection transformation in the case of believers alive at the second advent of christ is the means of gaining immortality (luke 20:35-36), while immortality guarantees that the glorious resurrection state is permanent. Whereas most greek philosophers believed that immortality implies solely the survival of the soul, the three great monotheistic religions (judaism, christianity and islam) consider that immortality is achieved through the resurrection of the body at the time of the final judgment the very same bodies that once constituted persons shall rise. The immortality of the soul and the resurrection of the body lecture by heinrich j vogel an essay on the scriptural doctrine of immortality by james challis eternity: christ's return, chiliasm, resurrection of the dead, judgment, hell, luther on eternity, heaven jp meyer, the northwestern lutheran , august 22, 1954, vol 41, # 17 to april. For some people it is the survival of the astral body resembling the physical body, for others the immortality of the immaterial soul and lastly the resurrection of the body basic definition of immortality is the unknown continuation of a person's existence, even after death.
The argument calls for a form of immortality of the soul and a lack of immortality of the body—the soul lives forever, the body perishes john hick in his excerpt from immortality and resurrection refutes the ideology that the spirit and body are dichotomous, one being everlasting and the other limited. The truth is, if man were an immortal soul in a material body—and if the death of the body released the soul—then there would be no need for a resurrection to immortal life man would merely continue living after death.
Body, and b) if the soul is of a different nature than the body it cannot be in it and if it is not in the body it cannot exist at all since there is no other place where it could be this assumes that for the soul to exist. This argument is a good example of one which seems to work only against a platonic, rather than a christian, view of life after death christians who think of life after death as a decision of god are in this respect different from platonists who regard the immortality of the soul as guaranteed by its nature. That belief is based on the false premise that each of us is an immortal soul living in a physical body, and when the body dies, the soul continues to live if that were true, then the soul would need some place to go when the body dies—which brings us to the common conceptions of heaven and hell.
Many ideas relating to our existence after death include the continuation of our genes thought our descendants, immortality of the soul, resurrection of the body, reincarnation and the idea that we live on in memories of others. Theologian oscar cullmann, in an essay published in the book immortality and resurrection, commented on this he wrote: if we were to ask an ordinary christian today what he conceives to be the new testament teaching concerning the fate of man after death, with few exceptions we should get the answer: 'the immortality of the soul'. Then, as in nygren's opinion it should ever be, rather on the resurrection of the body than on the immortality of the soul 2 an anglican erudite of the xviith century, henry dodwell this article first appeared as the resurrection of life in the bulletin of the harvard university divinity school . The doctrines of reincarnation and resurrection seem similar in that in both the immortality of the soul is essential belief in dualism - the dual nature of the human body into physical body and spiritual soul - goes back at least to the greeks.
Life after death, reincarnation, resurrection and immortality of the soul 1735 words 7 pages belief in life after death has taken many forms, some which are unique in particular religious belief systems, though others can be found in more than one religion. The prophet isaiah spoke not of an immortal soul but of a future resurrection of the dead: your dead shall live together with my dead body they shall arise awake and sing, you who dwell in dust for your dew is like the dew of herbs, and the earth shall cast out the dead (isaiah 26:19. In his essay the myth of immortality, clarence darrow explains his belief that life after death is a hoax and backs up his logic with logical reasoning.